“My wife and I had Upper Crust for our wedding. They did an absolutely fantastic job! Extremely professional, great communication, fantastic food, great service, and they are very willing to do the little details if needed (flexible!). They made us feel less stressed, we could trust them, and we feel like we received great value for the price we paid. I would recommend this caterer to anyone!!”

Drop-off catering and party trays, priced per tray
Hot entrées, sides, cold platters and desserts by the tray, delivered to your door or picked up at our Yorkville kitchen. No staff, no service charge, three days' notice. Most trays serve about 20.
What drop-off catering costs
Trays are priced per tray, not per person, and most serve about 20. There is no service charge and no staff. Delivery starts at $40 and depends on the town, or pick up at 109 E Hydraulic Ave in Yorkville for free. Sales tax is 9.25%. Drop-off orders need three days' notice.
- Hot entrée trays (see Entrées & Sides by the Tray): Chicken Oreganato $80 (serves 20, gluten free), Herb Roasted Chicken $80 (20 pieces), Pan Fried Chicken $80 (20 pieces), BBQ Pulled Pork $95 (serves 20), Yankee Pot Roast $125 (serves 20), Italian Beef Au Jus $90 or $150, Baked Mostaccioli $45 or $75, Baked Lasagna $50 or $90.
- Side trays: most $49, such as Mashed Potatoes, Buttered Fresh Green Beans, Potato Salad and Tossed Mixed Greens. Baked Macaroni & Cheese $59, Creamy Cole Slaw $55.
- Cold platters (see Hors d'oeuvres & Platters): Sandwich Platter $79, Deli Platter $95, Assorted Cheese Tray with Crackers $69 for 60 pieces, Fresh Vegetable Crudités $59, Seasonal Fresh Fruit Display $74.
- Hot appetizers: Cocktail Meatballs $64 for 100, Boneless Wings $69 for 60, Chicken Drummettes $100 for 120.
- Desserts: Assorted Home Baked Cookies $45 for 40, Brownies $59 for 35, Assorted Dessert Tray $59 for 40.
Drop-off versus a staffed event
With drop-off, the driver brings the trays at the time you set, lays them out with serving utensils if you ask, and leaves. You serve, you clear, you keep the leftovers. There is no 20% service charge and no event production fee, because there is no staff.
Pick drop-off for a backyard party, an open house, a team lunch, a church supper or a family gathering. Pick a staffed event when you want the buffet tended, tables cleared and nothing to think about; servers are $35 an hour with a four-hour minimum.
Sample: hot party trays for 20
- BBQ Pulled Pork, serves 20, $95
- Slider Sandwich Buns, 24 count, $12
- BBQ Baked Beans, $49
- Creamy Cole Slaw, $55
- Assorted Home Baked Cookies, 40 count, $45
Total $256, or $12.80 a person for 20. Plates, napkins and silverware are $1.50 per person ($30), and a chafing dish for each hot tray is $17. Delivery and tax are extra; pick-up is free.
Sample: cold party spread for 30
- Cheese & Sausage Tray with Crackers, 120 pieces, $79
- Fresh Vegetable Crudités, serves 25 to 30, $59
- Pinwheel Sandwiches, 60 pieces, $79
- Antipasto Kabobs, 50 pieces, $74
- Cocktail Meatballs, 100 pieces, $64
- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, 35 to 40 pieces, $69
Total $424, about $14.13 a person for 30. Disposable Appetizer Plates & Napkins are 99 cents per person. Delivery and tax are extra.
Keeping hot food hot
A Chafing Dish Package is $17 per hot dish: a wire-frame chafer, two sternos and a water pan, yours to keep with nothing to return. For a dressier table, stainless steel chafers rent for $20 a set and come back to us after the event. Our $17 wire-frame chafers are yours to keep, so there is nothing to return. Serving Tongs & Spoons are $1 each.
Where we deliver
Our kitchen is in Yorkville. Delivery is $40 to Oswego, Plano, Montgomery, Sugar Grove, Aurora, Plainfield, Sandwich, North Aurora and Batavia; $45 to Geneva and Naperville; $50 to St. Charles, Bolingbrook and Joliet. Ask for a quote or call or text (630) 553-9533.
What we usually serve at drop-off catering & party trays
Start from one of these. Every menu can be adjusted for headcount, budget and dietary needs.
Trays & plattersEntrées & Sides by the Tray
Each tray serves 20
Hot entrées, sides and salads by the tray, for pick-up or delivery. Build your own spread for a party, a crew or the office.
See the menu
Trays & plattersHors d'oeuvres & Platters
Warm, cool and sweet trays
Hot hors d'oeuvres, cold party platters on black lacquer trays, and homemade dessert trays, for pick-up or delivery.
See the menuThe dishes people ask for by name

BBQ Pulled Pork
$95.00 / trayBraised in our signature BBQ sauce, full of flavor and not too sweet.

Chicken Oreganato
$80.00 / trayMarinated in our herb rub blend and oven roasted until moist and tender. Breasts. Gluten free.
gluten free
Italian Beef Au Jus
$90.00 / trayMade fresh and seasoned to perfection. Hot & sweet peppers.

Baked Mostaccioli
$45.00 / tray
Sandwich Platter
$79.00 / trayFreshly made sandwiches on one platter.

Cheese & Sausage Tray with Crackers
$79.00 / tray
Cocktail Meatballs
$64.00 / traySwedish, Italian, or sweet & sour.

Assorted Home Baked Cookies
$45.00 / trayWhat our clients say
“Upper Crust just catered my daughter's bridal shower. The food was excellent and there was plenty of it. Staff was very professional, answered all of my questions and arrived on time for set up. I would definitely recommend Upper Crust catering.”
“We had some catering done by Upper Crust for our son's high school graduation. We had used them previously for a wedding reception as well. The food is always excellent and there were so many people who said how good it was. I have always been impressed with this company. They are kind and courteous and will always answer all your questions. Great job!!!”
Asked before every drop-off catering & party tray
More in the full FAQ, or just call (630) 553-9533.